Have you read those kids books “Who Would Win?” I have an 8 year old and I read a lot of these with him. They feature two powerhouse animals and breakdown which animal would beat the other in a match. I feel like this is kind of like that. Two powerhouse vacuums…which is better?
I’ll break down which I like for what in a little bit, but first you need to know a few things about my home, because how your home is set-up and how many people/pets are in your home absolutely makes a difference.
- We live in a ranch. It has a basement, so we have some stairs, but they aren’t used everyday.
- We have a vacuum solely for the basement. It’s an old Dyson in case you’re curious. We won’t be moving the animal Dyson down there.
- Prior to having the Dysons, we were going through 1 vacuum per year.
- We have 2 shedding dogs, 1 non-shedding dog, 2 people with long hair, and 2 people with short hair in our house. In other words, this is a HAIRY HOUSEHOLD!
- Our house is carpet in all the living areas, wood floor in the kitchen, tile in the bathrooms. Lots of transitions between rooms.
The Shark Performance Lift-Away (Left)
Age: 1 month
Cost: $180
Weight: 13 lbs
The Dyson Animal Ball Upright (Right)
Age: about 6 years
Cost: $350
Weight: 17 lbs
Maneuverability – Shark
Both vacuums pivot really well, but this is one of the places where the Dyson’s weight is a detriment. The dyson is harder to swivel and move. It can turn on a dime if you’re strong enough to move it, but I’m no Popeye!
On the other hand, the Shark is self-propelled and requires hardly any strength to guide it around furniture. It too turns on a dime and does so effortlessly. Definite winner here!
Stairs – Shark
We have about 15 stairs. This means the hoses are not long enough to cover the full height of the stairs. So, we’re carrying a vacuum on the stairs no matter which vacuum we use.
The wand on the Dyson is longer. So, if you have fewer stairs, you might be able to do them without needing to carry the vacuum with you. Or without the fear of the vacuum falling on you.
The weight of the Dyson makes our stairs an acrobatic feat and often makes me worried I’m going to slip and fall or the Dyson is going to come crashing down on me, but the Shark is able to lift off it’s base and you can carry it without the fear of the base crashing down on you. Have I mentioned that the Dyson has fallen on me more than once while doing the stairs? That sucker hurts!!
Hose – Dyson
I need to clarify that I’m not talking about the hose itself, but about the whole hose apparatus. Meaning the wand, hose, and accessories.
The Dyson has a really long hose, wand, and several accessories. It’s great for extending and reaching into longer crevices. Or just reaching the ground while standing.
The Shark is great, because it lifts off the base and can go anywhere, which is probably why the wand is shorter, but when you’re doing baseboards or trying to get under tables, you’re constantly hunched over with the short wand. In this case, longer is better!
Weight – Shark
I’ve mentioned several times already, so it shouldn’t be a surprise Shark wins in the weight category. Hands down.
I have bad shoulders/arms and I need something lighter to carry. The Shark is great!
Suction – Both
My husband swears the shark picks up more, but I don’t think so. I think they’re pretty even. Being in a house instead of a controlled test environment, there isn’t a way to accurately judge this. The more times I vacuum the same room, the more debris I will get. It doesn’t matter which vacuum I use. There’s too many people/animals in this house to get everything out of the carpet.
Switching Surfaces – Both
Both vacuums are good at going from carpet to wood, carpet to tile, or vice versa. They both have buttons to hit when you switch and it makes the transition pretty seamless.
Other – Shark
The Shark has a light. At first this was one of those features that I didn’t think would be useful, but it’s been really nice. Our house tends to have a lot of shadows and the light is helpful when going into the darker areas. It isn’t something that I would seek when buying a vacuum, but it’s an extra nice to have perk.
Overall Winner – Shark
At almost $200 cheaper, the Shark was the definite winner for us. The maneuverability and weight was what really sold me on the Shark. I always felt that the Dyson and I were having a competition of who could leverage their weight better and it always won. It seriously fell on top of me on the stairs more times than I’d like to admit. I never need to worry about the Shark landing on me, since the base is completely detachable. I will miss the wand length of the Dyson, but I’ll look for some accessories and see what’s out there to make up for the Shark’s short wand stature.
Do you have a favorite vacuum? Leave a comment, let me know which one you like!